Old Yorker

  • Primetime

    Lance Oppenheim (2026)

    Robert Pattinson, who came to prominence playing a vampire in the Twilight franchise, plays another in Primetime.  At least that’s how Pattinson has decided to portray Chris Hansen, the American television journalist.  As presenter of the reality TV series To Catch a Predator, which ran from 2004 to 2007 on NBC, Hansen tackled adult men who, after online chats with minors, were lured to a ‘sting house’, there to have sex with the underage person concerned.  Just as that was about to happen, Hansen would emerge to confront the would-be sex offender, who was often arrested as a result.  The minors Hansen saved weren’t actual minors but young adults, female and male, hired by the show because they passed for underage.  Nor were the men who featured in To Catch a Predator in any way public figures although, according to Primetime, Chris Hansen was eager for that to change – and it did, in late 2006.  A group of suspects in Murphy, Texas included Bill Conradt, assistant district attorney for Kaufman County in the north-east of the state.  Conradt, who had talked online and exchanged photographs with a young man posing as a thirteen-year-old boy, didn’t turn up at the undercover house.  When local police, accompanied by Hansen and an NBC camera crew, arrived instead at his home to serve an arrest warrant, Conradt shot himself there and then.  Chris Hansen excitedly anticipated that stinging a public official – particularly one holding legal office – would mean a quantum leap in his own celebrity.  In the event, the uproar resulting from Conradt’s suicide led to NBC’s halting production on To Catch a Predator.

    Primetime’s director, Lance Oppenheim, is only thirty but already well known for his documentaries.  The latest, You Can See Everything (co-directed with Nathan Fielder), has very recently opened in North America with a bang (an unusually loud bang for a non-fiction film on theatrical release).  Primetime, Oppenheim’s first dramatic feature for cinema, is entertaining – you want to know what happens next if, like me, you didn’t already know the true story.  But it’s also meretricious and has an insistent superiority complex:  working with a screenplay by Ajon Singh, Oppenheim exudes distaste for all concerned, the stung, the stingers and, above all, Chris Hansen – making the same points repeatedly and counterproductively.  Hansen is married with two young sons; neither the boys nor his wife, at home in Connecticut, seems nearly as important to him as his career, based in New York City.  But when To Catch a Predator’s soaring viewer ratings earn the show a primetime slot on NBC schedules, Hansen can’t wait to get back to tell his family the news.  He wakes his sleeping sons and has them watch him in TV action on videotape; when his wife (Anna Faris) asks if he woke the boys for some reason, Chris lies that they were already awake.  The wife’s manner is distinctly chilly (she knows her husband is unfaithful with other women), but he now tries to reconcile with her.  A sequence in their bedroom goes on for ages; once his wife has warmed up a bit, he tells her about the primetime slot, which was all he really wanted to do.  This punchline, as well as being pathetically obvious, completely fails to upstage Hansen’s disturbing his children’s sleep to plonk them in front of To Catch a Predator. 

    I kept wanting to say to the people on screen in Primetime, what did you expect?   Daniel Plum (Skyler Gisondo), a struggling actor trying to earn credits towards Screen Actors Guild membership, is cast as To Catch a Predator’s main ‘underage’ male decoy (Phoebe Bridgers plays his female counterpart, a much smaller role).   Dan’s approach to his new job is deadly serious; after his first appearance on the show, he talks on the phone with his friend and fellow acting hopeful Troy (Eric Rahill) and asks, ‘Did you think I was good?’  Troy, reasonably puzzled, says he supposes so but that no one watching To Catch a Predator is bothered about the decoy’s acting talents.  The culminating what-did-you-expect moment comes in the film’s climax, as Chris Hansen moves in for the kill – just what it turns out to be, though not in the way Hansen expects.  He persuades Decoy Dan (as he’s known on the team) to keep talking on the phone to Bill Conradt, as Hansen approaches Conradt’s front door to deliver the coup de grâce.  To Catch a Predator has depended heavily on hidden cameras in the sting house, but not here:  a horde of uniformed police and a camera crew, complete with flashing lights, encroach on the assistant DA’s house.  From an upstairs window, the appalled Conradt (Alex Winter) has a grandstand view of what’s happening.  Yet when he spoils things by putting a bullet through his brain, everyone on the ground, Hansen included, isn’t just shocked but utterly astonished.

    Hansen and his production team, headed by Andie Bender (Merritt Wever), work closely with Xavier Von Ercke (Matthew Maher), the founder of Perverted-Justice, a group of vigilante online paedophile-hunters.  (The dramatis personae include real people and fictional characters, composites or otherwise.  Like Hansen, Von Ercke is in the former category; Andie Bender and Dan Plum are in the latter.  Former NBC CEO Jeff Zucker has a cameo as himself:  he tells Chris and Andie in one breath that he doesn’t like their show, in the next announces its primetime promotion.)  Oppenheim does an efficient job of describing the mechanics of To Catch a Predator, which is useful, at least for the film’s audience this side of the Atlantic, and the competitive tensions between Andie and Xavier are illustrated neatly enough.  Merritt Wever, as usual, creates an absorbing character.  Andie’s mixture of heartless professionalism and unhappy, unwise allegiance to Hansen (ABC try unsuccessfully to poach her) is a rare asset in Primetime.  Laser-focused and easily charismatic, Robert Pattinson delivers probably the best performance I’ve yet seen from him.  There’s not much scope for nuance, though, because the filmmakers have it in for Chris Hansen so smugly and single-mindedly.

    The closest Primetime comes to interesting ambiguity is in a one-year-later postscript, by which time Hansen’s programme is about to be taken off air (the aftermath to Bill Conradt’s suicide was prolonged, according to Wikipedia).  This epilogue takes place in Mesa, Arizona, where Dan Plum is now living.  He opens the door to a neighbour, who hands Dan post delivered in error to him.  One of the envelopes includes Dan’s Screen Actors Guild card; a covering letter explains that his appearances on To Catch a Predator earned him enough points to qualify for SAG membership.  This moment earned plenty of ironic laughter in NFT1.  Lance Oppenheim at least has the decency, though, to let Skyler Gisondo’s face express that this is, in more ways than one, a poignant moment for his character.  Decoy Dan stayed absurdly conscientious about his strictly supporting role on a reality TV show.  Getting that SAG card seems no more than he deserves.

    29 October 2026

     

  • Ink

    Danny Boyle (2026)

    This certainly is the year for screen adaptations of hit stage plays by James Graham – the BBC miniseries of Dear England in the run-up to the World Cup, now the cinema version of Ink, showing at the London Film Festival ahead of general release.  First staged in London in 2017 (and on Broadway in 2019), Ink tells the story of The Sun’s first year of life under Rupert Murdoch, who bought the paper – at the time, a failing broadsheet – from IPC (International Publishing Corporation) in 1969; and of Murdoch’s relationship with Larry Lamb, the rebranded, tabloid Sun‘s first editor.  Danny Boyle’s film, with a screenplay by Graham, provides pacy entertainment of a pretty degraded kind.  Just like a red top rag, you might say:  for a while, I gave the filmmakers the benefit of the doubt and assumed this was their cunning intention, which it probably is.  But the film’s account of the notorious kidnap and murder of Muriel McKay, the wife of Murdoch’s deputy, put an end to my suspension of disgust.  Ink devotes plenty of screen time to this reconstruction of Mrs McKay’s terrifying ordeal, and it’s very crudely done – a surge of bad taste that can only be Danny Boyle’s.

    The film is always stuck between broadly realistic and cartoon treatment of its events and dramatis personae.  It’s hard to get a coherent sense of what impels Larry Lamb (Jack O’Connell) to accept Murdoch’s Sun offer in the first place.  Is Lamb selling his soul to the devil or trying to get rid of the working-class chip on his shoulder or taking revenge on Hugh Cudlipp, IPC chairman and his former boss at the Daily Mirror, for not giving Lamb the editor job he felt he deserved?  It might, of course, be a combination of all three, but as the months go by, Lamb’s motivation in driving up circulation unscrupulously seems too narrowly focused on winning the contest for readers, especially those defecting from the Mirror.  (Boyle punctuates the narrative with a visual scoreboard – shots of a circulation graph on the Sun newsroom wall.)  Jack O’Connell plays Lamb competently, but the script gives him little chance to go deeper into character (and O’Connell, even though he’s from nearby Derbyshire, is never deep into his put-on Yorkshire accent).

    Guy Pearce is a bigger disappointment.  Those who (like me) didn’t see Ink on stage can be forgiven for expecting Rupert Murdoch to be the plum role – a luridly colourful monster always calling the tune, with Larry Lamb the relative straight man.  It turns out to be not as simple as that; in view of what Murdoch has become in the public mind, the bits in Ink where he’s shown as equivocal and anxious not to offend, are quite amusing.  The trouble is that Guy Pearce is rather bland, even as the Mephistophelean Murdoch.  For me, expectations of a vilely entertaining Dirty Digger were also shaped by knowing that a different actor played Murdoch on stage, in the original Almeida Theatre production, on the West End and on Broadway.  Bertie Carvel’s Tony- and Olivier-winning turn may have been top-notch caricature, but you get a sense even from brief YouTube clips of Carvel’s wit and dynamism in the role.  Pearce has neither and trying to bring depth to Murdoch – if that’s what Pearce is trying to do – is pointless when James Graham’s writing of the character is lively but shallow.  Having Bertie Carvel in the film’s cast – in what feels like, in effect, the consolation role of repeatedly thwarted Hugh Cudlipp – makes matters worse.  You’re more acutely aware of what you’re missing in Guy Pearce’s performance.

    Claire Foy is good, as usual, though the character of Jules Davis, Lamb’s mistress and a key member of his team of Sun journalists, doesn’t add up.  It comes as no surprise that Jules is ‘an amalgam of various female journalists who worked on Fleet Street at the time’ (Wikipedia).  Jules is sometimes as keen as Lamb or Murdoch to take an outrageous lead, sometimes – as in Lamb’s increasingly brazen exploitation of page 3 girls – shocked by his ruthless tactics.  Journalistic shamelessness seems to pass from one character to another in Ink, according to the requirements of individual scenes.  When a successful stage play becomes a mediocre or worse screen piece, it’s a common refrain from the play’s admirers that you-should-have-seen-it-in-the-theatre, where it was very different and wonderful (The History Boys syndrome).  You could sort of believe this with Graham’s Dear England.  The four-part TV version was already repetitive with three parts to go; under the camera’s scrutiny Joseph Fiennes, reprising his National Theatre role, seemed to be impersonating Gareth Southgate in excruciating slow motion.  Most of the interest came from clips of actual World Cup and Euros matches, even though these also felt like padding.  But Dear England on stage ran less than three hours, including interval, compared with the nearly four hours of the tele-dramatisation:  that is a big difference.  It’s harder to think that Ink is essentially much changed from the theatre.  The stage play, although it covers The Sun‘s controversial handling of events around Muriel McKay’s abduction, presumably doesn’t include the speculative reconstruction served up by the film.  Inflation of Graham’s original clearly wasn’t an issue here, though:  Ink runs nearly three hours, including interval, in the theatre; Danny Boyle’s film is a few minutes under two hours.

    The screen Ink does a reasonable job of sketching in the processes and industrial politics of the British press world of the time (even though the real Rupert Murdoch’s appearance in a couple of newsreel clips within the main action, rather than a final-credits postscript, is jarring).  The film is careless about smaller period details.  The timeframe is very clearly 1969-1970.  One of Boyle’s montages to illustrate the-way-we-lived-then includes a clip from The Generation Game, which began on BBC in autumn 1971.  Bits about England’s World Cup preparations in the spring of 1970 include the Match of the Day theme tune – except that it didn’t become the theme tune until the start of the 1970-71 domestic season.  (I remember Michael Aspel at the time describing Barry Stoller’s now-immortal music as a ‘Mexico hangover’.)  The longer Ink goes on, the more you wonder how far Danny Boyle, rather than The Sun, will go in pursuit of a bit of crummy attention-grabbing – like the AI-generated likeness of Margaret Thatcher that briefly turns up in Lamb’s office, where he often sleeps:  that’s what he’s doing when the Prime Minister arrives to announce his knighthood (‘Arise, Sir Larry’).  This isn’t a chronological mistake but a deliberate flash forward to 1980, and Ink’s concluding montage demonstrates the increasing corruption of media ethics over the course of subsequent decades, pinning the blame for all that on the first meeting of Lamb and Murdoch at Rules restaurant in Covent Garden, with which the film began.  This parting shot comes across as pompously simplistic – and more than a touch pot-calling-the-kettle-black, given the ethical standards of filmmaking on show in Ink.

    18 October 2026

     

     

     

Posts navigation