Old Yorker

  • Woman Unknown

    Kvinde ukendt

    May el-Toukhy (2026)

    I try to include in my London Film Festival selections one or two seemingly low-profile films that might not go on general release any time soon.  These taking-a-punt choices are sometimes rewarding (Ernst De Geer’s The Hypnosis (2023)), sometimes not (Stroma Cairns’ The Son and the Sea (2025)).  This year, after reading through brief synopses in the LFF programme, I went for Woman Unknown, the third cinema feature by Danish writer-director May el-Toukhy.  A couple of days after I’d booked, the Venice Film Festival jury awarded the film the Golden Lion and Mathilde Arcel, who plays the title character, the Volpi Cup for Best Actress.  I felt a twinge of disappointment that I could no longer discover a hidden gem.  That was nothing beside the disappointment I feel after seeing Woman Unknown.

    The story, which May el-Toukhy wrote with Maren Louise Käehne, takes place in Copenhagen in 1945, just after Denmark’s liberation from German occupation.  Marie (Mathilde Arcel) lives in the home of Christian (Carsten Bjørnlund), a wealthy businessman and factory owner, and a widower.  Although she’s presently one of the staff there, a maid and nanny to Christian’s young daughter Leonora (Flora Yde Sander), Marie’s household role is soon revealed to be much larger – and how she routinely moves between its different aspects is striking.  In the opening sequence, it’s early morning.  Marie gets up from the bed she’s sharing with Christian, washes and dresses in her housemaid’s uniform.  After a few words with other servants in the kitchen, she goes to the dining room, where Christian is alone at the breakfast table.  She pours his coffee.  They share a brief moment of intimacy just as the housekeeper, Esther (Marina Bouras), enters the room.  She doesn’t bat an eyelid; Esther already knows, like Christian’s other staff, that the master sleeps with Marie, to whom he’s engaged to be married.  Once Christian has left for the office, Esther apprises Marie – as prospective lady of the house – of the evening’s dinner menu.  Marie takes Leonora to school before heading into town on an important errand.  She’s taking what will be her bridal gown – which was also Christian’s first wife’s wedding dress – to a tailor, for alterations to be made.  So far, so interesting, but a chance encounter on the tram into town threatens to sabotage Marie’s future and starts Woman Unknown’s journey into engineered and bizarrely improbable melodrama.

    The young man who calls out Marie’s name on the crowded tram is Karl (Thorbjørn Hedegaard).  She turns, recognises him instantly, then pretends not to have heard.  Karl is persistent, though.  It will soon emerge that before they came to Copenhagen he and Marie lived in the same village; that Karl carried a torch for Marie; that during the occupation she had an affair with a German soldier and bore his child, which was stillborn; that Marie’s parents are not dead (as she has told motherless Leonora) but estranged from their disgraced daughter.  In short, Marie has tried to erase her past to secure a comfortable future with Christian, while Karl is doing menial work and living in virtual squalor, and has plenty of reasons to blackmail her.  I began to lose faith in el-Toukhy’s storytelling very soon after Karl appeared on the scene.  Once they’ve left the tram, although Marie tries to get rid of him, Karl persuades her to go for a drink.  While he’s at the bar, she slips out and goes on her way to the tailor’s – without the package containing the wedding dress.  We could believe that, in her panic to get away from Karl, she might have left the dress behind, important as it is.  We can’t believe she’s so distracted still not to notice this when she enters the tailor’s premises, goes up the stairs and starts talking with the tailor (Mikael Birkkjær).  Only when he asks for the dress does Marie realise she no longer has it.

    This may seem minor, but it foreshadows May el-Toukhy’s cavalier approach to plausibility.  That approach is yoked to a firm determination to present Marie, and women more generally, as the victims of men.  Karl opens the package Marie leaves behind, discovers from the contents her home address and returns the package there.  Next morning, the glass in the entrance to the apartment building is disfigured by a swastika in red paint.  Assuming that Karl must be responsible, Marie seeks him out and offers money in exchange for his silence.  He’s more interested in sexual coercion – improbably, given his situation – though he doesn’t order Marie to strip naked:  she does that without prompting.  Karl gropes Marie, aggressively enters her, tells her to open her mouth and, when she obeys, spits inside it.  Did May el-Toukhy think these weren’t enough to convey the extent of Karl’s abuse and Marie’s humiliation – that it was necessary for her also to undress and pose full frontal nude, for the camera as well as for Karl (who doesn’t undress)?

    Unknown Woman has a few echoes of Sophie’s Choice (and fainter ones of Rebecca) but we never learn more about the circumstances of Marie’s affair with the German.  The film is interested in her not as an individual but as a representative of women on the receiving end of appalling male treatment.  (A couple of rapid flashbacks to her past – seemingly in Marie’s memory – are so splintered it’s hard to work out what they’re showing.)  Marie’s gruesome experience with Karl isn’t the only episode of its kind.  Other, anonymous women who had similar wartime affairs, are ritually shamed in the streets of Copenhagen by a jostling, jeering mob:  the women’s heads are shaved, they’re stripped and branded ‘Nazi whores’, swastikas are daubed on their bodies, and so on.  All these scenes are supposedly unobjectionable because there isn’t a male gaze from the director’s chair.  The male gaze on camera, though, is usually sinister.  In an early scene, Marie needs to renew a prescription for liquid opium to reduce pain from the internal scar tissue that’s a legacy of her difficult labour and at its worst whenever Christian has sex with her.  The usual doctor isn’t available; a new one (Joen Højerslev), stony-faced and wearing creepy spectacles, insists on physically examining Marie.  May el-Toukhy thus encourages the audience, like Marie, to fear what’s coming next, even though the doctor turns out to be professionally helpful.  Once alterations to the wedding dress have been made, Marie returns for a fitting.  The tailor seems to ogle her rather than appraise his work.

    The post-war consequences for male collaborators, moneyed ones at any rate, are a different matter.  Christian hosts a dinner party for some local bigwigs and their wives.  The gathering is briefly in jeopardy, thanks to the painted swastika, which arrives on the day of the party.  Christian thinks removing the swastika immediately might look suspicious and insists the dinner party goes ahead.  A few guests pull out, but the host is vindicated:  come the evening May el-Toukhy has virtually forgotten the controversy and has other priorities.  Christian’s firm makes gloves; Marie wears a pair of the latest ones to the dinner party, so that Christian can advertise his products; a couple of guests – male not female – examine the gloves admiringly, barely acknowledging the woman wearing them.  At the dinner table the men congratulate themselves on how ‘adaptable’ they were during the German occupation.  In another scene, Marie accuses Christian of having collaborated with the Germans by selling goods to them.  His pragmatic justification for doing so – keeping not just his business running but his Danish workforce in paid employment – didn’t sound entirely unreasonable to me though, from audible audience reactions at this screening in NFT1, I think I was in a minority.

    Although Christian and his household seem to occupy most of the apartment block, there is at least one other resident, Mrs Berg (Sofia Nolsøe) – bohemian and free-spirited, a single mother, who often wears trousers.  Her small apartment faces onto Marie’s room, allowing the protagonist to observe the life of a contrasting liberated woman.  Marie is on friendly terms with this neighbour, occasionally babysitting her young son, but, in a desperate attempt to deflect suspicion that the swastika on the entrance may be to do with her, casts collaborationist aspersions on Mrs Berg.  This act of self-protecting betrayal leads to police arriving to question and arrest Mrs Berg; when she resists, one of the officers fires a gun, with fatal results (the orphaned son is taken into state care).  Marie for a while loses control.  After dark, she wanders out into the city alone, gets drunk, throws herself at a man and, when he pushes her away, falls down some steps.  She’s knocked out but somehow gets back home before daybreak, her face injured.  Christian explains to Esther that Marie slipped and fell in the bathroom during the night, but warns Marie privately that, if there’s any repetition of such erratic behaviour, their marriage can’t go ahead.  He doesn’t, though, seem to know quite what the erratic behaviour was – just as he never discovers Marie’s bigger secret.

    May el-Toukhy and Maren Louise Käehne’s ability to tell a decent story through persuasive characters and plotting is repeatedly compromised by their gender-political mission.  Karl, after setting things in motion, exits the film entirely – not because this is what he might realistically do but because keeping him in the narrative would create complications the filmmakers want to avoid.  It’s strongly implied that Christian’s second marriage will be a loveless marriage of convenience – Marie will supply sex and childcare – and that his chief concerns are his own security and reputation, and keeping up appearances.  So why does the fiancée that he’s keen to display socially still partly work as a housemaid?  As an occasional, as it were official, reminder of Marie’s subservience.  If Christian insists on wifely obedience and propriety, wouldn’t Marie’s outspoken censure of his accommodation of the Nazis and her unexplained night on the town, with the risk of gossip below stairs or even beyond the household that might result from it, be enough to put him off marrying her?  No, because the marriage must go ahead, as the culmination of Marie’s denial-of-who-she-really-is-in-order-to-survive.  The theatrical release poster for Woman Unknown (which appears on its Wikipedia entry) is succinctly expressive:  the image of a woman from the shoulders upwards, her facial features invisible under a broad smear of red paint.  The film’s closing scene returns to the tailor’s premises and Marie in the wedding gown.  This time, Christian has joined the tailor to assess the bride-to-be-cum-mannequin.  They don’t, of course, look at Marie’s face, but the camera does.  Her expression is blank.

    Mathilde Arcel gives a remarkable, dominant performance as Marie, even though her courage and commitment in the role are offensively exploited.  Carsten Bjørnlund has proved in a succession of Danish television parts what a good actor he is:  it’s frustrating that his character here is so weakly written (there’s no indication even of what Christian felt about his first wife or feels about their daughter).  Although I don’t know either of May el-Toukhy’s two previous cinema features (Long Story Short (2015), Queen of Hearts (2019)), I’ve seen and liked her TV work, too – as the director of episodes of acclaimed drama series like The Legacy (on which she worked with Bjørnlund), Ride Upon the Storm and Cry Wolf.  She also directed a couple of the later episodes of The Crown.  Maren Louise Käehne, who has shared the screenplay credit with el-Toukhy on all three of her films, successfully adapted Kerstin Ekman’s novel Blackwater for television.  You’d never guess from Woman Unknown that el-Toukhy and Käehne are both capable of so much better.

    This NFT1 screening was introduced by Sarah Lutton, who described the film as a multifaceted portrait of a woman negotiating the gendered hypocrisy of post-war Denmark, as deeply intentional filmmaking, and so on.  Her words sounded like a parody of right-on cine-babble, though I must admit that Lutton wasn’t too wide of the mark, at least if you take out ‘multifaceted’ and if intentionality in this context means subordinating to a key message any considerations of balanced reality.   This Golden Lion winner may well collect more prizes but comes perilously close to saying that 1940s Danish patriarchy and expediency were worse than German Nazism.  If that is May el-Toukhy’s view she’s entitled to express it, of course, but her imposed agenda and contrivance ruin Woman Unknown as credible drama.

    17 October 2026

  • Fatherland

    Ojczyzna

    Paweł Pawlikowski (2026)

    Germany in the aftermath of World War II is no stranger to the cinema screen either as newsreel footage or as drama.  The East-West contest for the strategic upper hand as the Cold War gets chillier is a familiar movie subject.  But Paweł Pawlikowski’s Fatherland, which premiered at Cannes this year and is showing at the London Film Festival just before general release in the UK, explores this political time and place from an unusual perspective.  Thomas Mann, Nobel laureate and the country’s pre-eminent man of letters, had lived abroad, mostly in the USA, since 1933.  In 1949 he accepted an invitation to return to Germany, to mark the bicentenary of Goethe’s birth.  Mann visited Frankfurt, where Goethe was born and grew up, and Weimar, where he spent much of his life and died.  By 1949, Frankfurt was part of West Germany and Weimar part of East Germany.  Pawlikowski describes attempts made by the two German regimes to claim Mann and, through him, Goethe, as their own, and the effects of this cultural tug-of-war – and of a family tragedy that coincides with the visit – on Mann (Hanns Zischler) and his daughter Erika (Sandra Hüller), who is her father’s travelling companion, car driver and, when needed, his interpreter.

    There are occasional images of post-war urban rubble, but well-appointed halls, theatres and other institutional spaces are more usual scenery in Fatherland, as Mann gives speeches and press conferences and receives a Goethe Prize on each side of the Iron Curtain.  Two other kinds of interior – hotel rooms and sequences shot from inside the Manns’ car – create a different impression.  The rooms help convey a sense of the characters’ unsettledness, even dislocation, in their present surroundings.  Driver’s-eye-view shots of the roads ahead give off a bleak anonymity.  Both ideas may sound rather obvious; they don’t come across that way because Pawlikowski works them into a richer texture of the Manns’ belonging and not belonging.  Responding to an international group of journalists, they answer questions in German, French and English.  Their breadth of cultural understanding, in combination with these language skills, might seem to qualify them as world citizens.  Yet circumstances have forced the Manns to live far from home, and the Germany to which they temporarily return isn’t Heimat.  Here, too, Pawlikowski in effect supplies a novel take on a frequent subject of films set in the years just after World War II.  Compared with the post-war refugees across Europe that we’re used to seeing on the screen, Thomas and Erika Mann are incomparably privileged in material terms.  They might still be described as emotionally stateless persons.

    The film’s opening scene takes place in a different interior in another country – an apartment in Cannes, where Klaus Mann (August Diehl) is on the telephone to Erika (unseen throughout the conversation).  A younger man gets out of the bed that he appears to have been sharing with Klaus, and leaves the apartment, as Klaus sits beside the bed, bemoaning the state of contemporary art and his own writing, while his sister encourages him to join her and their father on the trip to Germany.  Klaus isn’t seen again.  Erika learns of his suicide while the Manns are still in Frankfurt.  When she tells Thomas, he insists on sticking to his visit schedule:  his youngest son, Michael, a professional viola player, happens to be in Cannes with a touring orchestra – he’ll see to the arrangements for Klaus’ funeral.  Fatherland derives from actual events – Thomas Mann did visit Germany in 1949, by invitation and to receive the Goethe Prize – though Pawlikowski’s screenplay, which he wrote with Hendrik Handloegten, takes some sizeable liberties with the facts to give greater salience to the film’s central concerns.  Mann was accompanied on the trip not by his daughter but by his wife Katia (and their chauffeur).  Klaus Mann had committed suicide shortly before his parents’ trip to Europe.

    It helps to be clued up in advance about a few things to do with the Manns.  During Erika’s conversation with American journalist Betty Knox (Anna Madeley), whom she got to know when both were working in London during World War II, there’s a passing reference to Erika’s husband, W H Auden.  They married in 1935 for the sole purpose of securing British citizenship for Erika (they never lived together but were still legally married at the time of her death in 1969).  This matters not just as a cultural detail but as a variation on Fatherland ‘s theme of unbelonging, the gap between paper proof of national or personal identity and corresponding emotional experience.  At the same drinks reception Erika bumps into the actor and theatre director Gustaf Gründgens (Joachim Meyerhoff) – her former husband, sometime lover of Klaus Mann and notorious associate of Hermann Göring.  When Erika takes the opportunity to deplore his complicity with the Nazi regime, Gründgens – known to some of us courtesy of István Szabó’s Mephisto (1981) – scorns the relative life of luxury that Erika has enjoyed in exile, thanks to her father, her multilingualism, her network of useful contacts.  To the surprise of other reception guests, she slaps Gründgens’ face, hard.

    This takes the film’s audience by surprise, too.  It has impact because it shows Erika behaving in an unaccustomed way.  She’s mostly quietly spoken, although Sandra Hüller makes highly incisive transitions between Erika’s public and private faces.  She understands and accepts the job she’s expected to do for her renowned father.  Yet she’s ready to show grief at Klaus’s death or to tell Thomas, when they’re alone together, that his fine words are mere background ‘to a show that the Americans and Russians are now running’.  Hüller is finely partnered by veteran actor Hanns Zischler (whose cinema work goes all the way back to early Wim Wenders films of the 1970s).  The Manns’ car journeys obviously influenced this thought, but Zischler occasionally reminded me of Victor Sjöström as the elderly professor in Bergman’s Wild Strawberries (1957), though Hanns Zischler also gives Thomas Mann a curiously businesslike quality.

    Like the other Sandra Hüller film showing at the LFF, Markus Schleinzer’s Rose, Fatherland has black-and-white photography.  It’s the third consecutive Pawlikowski film, after Ida (2013) and Cold War (2018), to be shot on monochrome, and by the same gifted cinematographer, Łukasz Żal.  Also as with Rose, this visual choice fits the solemn subject matter; besides, 1949 is a time that most people alive today think of as a black-and-white era.  The assortment of music in Fatherland is thoroughly apt and fascinating.  It includes, inter alia:  a popular easy-listening number, performed during a banquet given in Mann’s honour; drunken German ex-soldiers bawling fascist songs in the street outside Erika’s hotel room’s open window (until she angrily slams it shut); in Weimar, the East German national anthem, ‘Auferstanden aus Ruinen’ (‘Risen from Ruins’); the Mills Brothers’ ‘Tiger Rag’ on US forces network, playing on the car radio; and, in the film’s memorable conclusion, Bach’s ‘Jesu, Joy of Man’s Desiring’, which Mann and his daughter hear played on the organ in a bomb-damaged church they enter during their journey back to Frankfurt.

    Each of the two Germanys may want to claim Mann as its cultural figurehead but his status brings with it risks and demands on the part of vested interests.  In Frankfurt, Erika intercepts anonymous letters accusing her father of treachery to ‘the Fatherland’.  At the press conference, journalists suggest that, if Mann engages with East Germany, he’s liable to suffer for it when he returns to the US.  Two of Wagner’s grandsons unsuccessfully lobby Mann to help revive the Bayreuth Festival.  In Weimar, a man bursts into his hotel room, urging Mann to use the speech he’s about to make to reveal that the Soviet military administration in East Germany is detaining political prisoners at the former Nazi camp of Buchenwald.  Mann declines this plea too, adhering to his prepared text about German literature and cultural reunification.  Because he also adheres stubbornly to Goethe’s vision of the ‘good Germany’ – expressed in the country’s art, especially its literature and classical music, rather than in its political and military history.

    Thomas Mann believes in a good Germany but is he a good father?  Erika is angered by his apparently insensitive reaction to Klaus’s death, but things change in the final scenes of Fatherland.  Thomas tells his daughter, as they prepare to travel back West, that last night he dreamed of Klaus.  In that sequence in the ruined church, Mann weeps as the Bach music plays.  Erika takes his hand, and says, ‘Let’s go home’.  Just as the moment when Erika smacks Gustaf Gründgens hits home in more ways than one, so Mann’s tears are the payoff for Hanns Zischler’s emotional moderation in what has gone before. This closing scene is powerfully ambiguous and crystallises Paweł Pawlikowski’s key themes.  How much is Mann in mourning for his son, how much for the political and incipient cultural fission of his country?  He and Erika can hold hands as West and East Germany can’t.  It’s almost unnecessary for Mann, in response to his daughter’s consoling ‘Let’s go home’, to murmur, ‘Where is that?’  Fatherland is remarkably succinct, running only eighty-two minutes.  It’s by some way the shortest film I’ve so far seen at this year’s London Film Festival, and by some way the best[1].

    15 October 2026

    [1] Afternote:  That was still the case – on both counts – at the end of the Festival!

Posts navigation