Film review

  • All Fall Down

    John Frankenheimer (1962)

    This adaptation by William Inge of James Leo Herlihy’s 1960 novel begins with a shot of a Greyhound bus on which sixteen-year-old Clinton Willarts is travelling.  His voice on the soundtrack tells us, excitedly, that he’s en route to meet his big brother Berry-Berry (this peculiar name is never explained).  All Fall Down is the story of how Clinton comes of age.   He embraces life (whereas Berry-Berry, as he says explicitly at one point, hates it), stops hero-worshipping his glamorously feckless brother, and begins to see his unhappy parents, Ralph and Annabel (the two sons call them by their first names), in a different light.  Clinton’s bus journey at the start is taking him from his home in Cleveland, Ohio to the Florida Keys.  He has two hundred dollars in his pocket – the money Berry-Berry needs to set up a shrimp boat business.  When Clinton arrives in Florida, he discovers that Berry-Berry is in jail, for assaulting a prostitute.  The prison officer tells Clinton that two hundred dollars was the amount set for his brother’s bail and decides to release Berry-Berry in exchange for the cash.    Penniless, the two brothers start walking back in the direction from which the Greyhound bus came.

    They eventually hitch a lift with two young women who like the look of Berry-Berry; in a hotel bar somewhere else in Florida a sex-starved middle-aged woman takes a shine to him too.  She supplies the money needed for Clinton’s fare back to Cleveland and Berry-Berry disappears with her.  Clinton grins happily when he first sees his brother and he says, ‘Gee, I’ll miss you, Berry-Berry’ (he appends the name to almost every sentence he speaks) when they go their separate ways.  Beyond that, we don’t get much sense of what the rapid succession of events in Florida mean to him – even though it must be an extraordinary experience for a schoolboy who seems not to have been away from home before.  Once he’s back in Cleveland, we learn that Clinton spends much of his time filling notebooks with the conversations he overhears, including those of his parents.   Annabel thinks this is unnatural behaviour even if Clinton is, as she says, ‘some kind of genius’. (I don’t know to what extent All Fall Down is autobiographical but Clinton’s transcription mania tends to suggest the character in the story will grow up to be the writer who created that character.)  But, as played by Brandon deWilde, the boy is so affably innocent and – without a voiceover to help him – reacts so weakly to the ensuing melodrama that he seems more simple-minded than perceptive.

    Brandon deWilde cuts an unfortunate figure in All Fall Down in more ways than one.   In retrospect, it’s very sad to hear Clinton’s affirmation that he loves life spoken by an actor who died young (and in a motor accident – which is what triggers the climax to this film).   DeWilde is also unprepossessing as a presence and as an actor.   That’s not the way of all child stars grown up but it’s certainly what happened in this case.  As a seven-year-old in 1950, deWilde came to prominence in the original Broadway production of The Member of the Wedding;  he appeared in Fred Zinnemann’s film version in 1952 and, the following year, enjoyed his greatest success as the child in Shane.   A decade later, deWilde had filled out without growing tall; as Clinton, he’s broad in the beam.  He doesn’t have the same bulkiness a year later in Hud.  Otherwise, what I put in my note of that film anticipates almost exactly the impression deWilde makes in All Fall Down:

    ‘… there’s a sadness about his presence here, because of that association [with Shane], because the actor was dead in 1972 at the age of 30 – and, though it seems unkind to say so, because of the gulf between deWilde’s interpretative skills and those of the other three principals.’

    In All Fall Down there are four other principals:  Karl Malden (Ralph), Angela Lansbury (Annabel), Warren Beatty (Berry-Berry) and Eva Marie Saint, as Echo, the daughter of an old friend of Annabel, who’s a house guest with the Willarts and who detains Berry-Berry there when he eventually returns to Cleveland.  Although physically right for the role, Beatty isn’t at his best here.  In the scenes in which Berry-Berry gives sexually indigent women what they want – the woman in the Florida bar (Constance Ford), a schoolteacher (Barbara Baxley) who drives into the garage where he’s working at the time – Beatty’s good at getting across the character’s seductive expertise and the mixture of self-satisfaction and self-disgust that produces in him.   He’s less persuasive when Berry-Berry’s in a ‘serious’ relationship with Echo and he can’t bring to life the young man’s physically abusive side (the teacher also is on the receiving end of this when things turn sour), which should be shocking.  When the camera closes in for what are meant to be moments of truth in the later stages, Beatty is strained and inexpressive.

    In spite of these weaknesses his magnetism is crucial in delivering the strongest element of All Fall Down – the inadvertently man-eating propensities of Annabel Willart and, in particular, her relationship with her elder son.   This Freudian mother is a dramatic cliché – as is her exhausting chatterbox behaviour – but the explicitness of Annabel’s passion for Berry-Berry is startling and affecting.   John Frankenheimer certainly knew how to get the best out of Angela Lansbury.  As Annabel, she’s not as consistently brilliant as she was in The Manchurian Candidate later in the same year but she’s physically daring and emotionally fearless:  when Berry-Berry comes home and Annabel gazes at and moves towards him as if he were a returning lover; when she frankly describes to her husband her envious resentment of Echo (whom Annabel likes very much) once she and Berry-Berry have fallen in love; when she leaps from her chair and onto the floor to rescue the framed photograph of Berry-Berry that Clinton tries to destroy.  Thanks to Lansbury’s histrionic power, Beatty seems more at ease in his scenes with her, where his disengagement from the role fuses satisfyingly with Berry-Berry’s taking care to shut himself from his mother.   There’s a connection too between Lansbury’s natural acting style and the character she’s playing.  She’s an emphatic performer, even in small details.  This gives an extra edge to Annabel’s unfailing tendency to push too hard and, as a result, suffocate the men in the family.  Annabel isn’t meant to be the main character but Angela Lansbury is the central dynamic of All Fall Down – she’s both the centre of attention and helps to enhance what her co-stars do.

    The only way that Annabel can keep Berry-Berry under the same roof as her is through his being attracted to another woman on the premises – the effectiveness of this irony obscures the very basic plotting which gets Echo into the house at the right time.   (This is the kind of engineering that works better in a stage play with a single set, which temporarily becomes the whole world.)  Just as Annabel causes her sons – and her husband – to back off, so Echo draws all three men to her.  Eva Marie Saint is able, through her more delicate presence and less forceful acting, to complement Angela Lansbury’s performance and to make this obvious idea plausible.   Saint too is playing a stock character – a beauty who is mysteriously alone and who has an unhappy love affair to explain her solitude – but her elegance makes Echo’s idiosyncrasies charming.  (She not only drives a handsome car but knows how to fix the engine when it breaks down.  The ironic pattern of the writing dictates of course that this lover of motors dies in one.)     Ralph Willart is a crudely eccentric character, a practising socialist who’s retired from a career in real estate to drink himself to death and fail to complete jigsaws.  Karl Malden is probably miscast in the role but he’s such a strong and truthful actor that he makes it work – you believe that Ralph’s effortful humour is a way of maintaining an identity in the household.  There’s a touching moment when Annabel tells Ralph she’s always admired his ability to cope in a crisis; he says nothing but we feel his surprised gratitude.

    According to Wikipedia, William Inge became known as ‘the Playwright of the Midwest’ but he displays an appetite for sexual melodrama that seems to belong further south.   John Frankenheimer may be uncomfortable in Florida:  the floozies in a bar on the Florida Keys, the bar owner/bouncer (Madame Spivy) who throws Clinton out in a pointlessly energetic fashion, the prison officers – all these cameos are badly overdrawn.   Back in Cleveland, too much screen time is spent on the night before Christmas (cross-cutting to Berry-Berry’s antics in Louisville, Kentucky, where he’s gone with the hapless teacher).  Although Angela Lansbury is very fine in the scene with Clinton by the family Christmas tree, the following sequence, in which Ralph invites three tramps into the house, goes on way too long and seems to belong in a different movie.   All Fall Down is infused with the same drive to present the American family as garishly dysfunctional that impelled Inge’s screenplay for Splendor in the Grass but which is merged here with a getting-of- manhood structure that’s both more affirmative and more generic – and which makes Brandon deWilde’s shortcomings a more serious weakness than they might otherwise be.  For all its faults, I was fascinated by the film.   Frankenheimer’s direction is uneven but All Fall Down is visually interesting all the way through.  It has a conventional ‘hopeful’ ending but this comes too late and too feebly to detract from the bizarre but unarguable emotional power of much of what’s gone before.

    8 June 2012

  • The Arbor

     Clio Barnard (2010)

    Clio Barnard’s film is about the writer Andrea Dunbar, who became famous at the age of eighteen through her autobiographical play The Arbor, staged at the Royal Court in 1980 and subsequently in New York.  Dunbar had a further success with Rita, Sue and Bob, Too! a couple of years later:  like The Arbor, this was set in a run-down part of Bradford, where the author grew up and continued to live.  She developed serious alcohol problems before dying of a brain haemorrhage in the toilets of a local pub a few days before Christmas 1989.  Barnard’s film is also about the family that survived Andrea, especially her elder daughter Lorraine, who has spent much of her young life in prison – most notoriously for the manslaughter of her infant son Harris.  Lorraine was a heroin addict and the baby boy exhibited persistent signs of drug addiction before swallowing the teaspoon of methadone that killed him at the age of two.

    Barnard presents the material in three different ways.  There are clips from television documentaries about Andrea Dunbar and her family (an Arena programme screened in March 1980 and another documentary made a year before her death).   There are performances of scenes from the stage play The Arbor.   (To distinguish between references to these and to the film itself, I’m going to call the stage play Brafferton Arbor, the street where Dunbar lived and which ‘the Arbor’ is short for.  According to Max Stafford-Clark, the manuscript for the play originally submitted by Dunbar to the Young Writers’ Festival at the Royal Court – in green ink, in an exercise book – was headed ‘Brafferton Arbor’.)  These are outdoor sequences shot on the Buttershaw estate in Bradford with an audience of onlookers standing outside houses and round about.  (A few of these are actors playing 2010 versions of people who knew Andrea Dunbar; most of them are, we assume, people who actually live on the estate now.)   Sometimes the excerpts from Brafferton Arbor are open-air theatre with no pretence at naturalism – the actors sit al fresco on the three-piece suite that was presumably used for the stage set, or on chairs which are meant to represent the seats on a bus.  Sometimes the excerpts are staged as if they were part of a cinema piece – the Andrea character in the play walks down the street with the Asian man whose child she’s carrying or sits on a wall talking with one or other of the neighbourhood girls.   The third and most striking element of The Arbor consists of actors lip-synching the words of the people actually involved with Andrea Dunbar and whom Barnard interviewed and recorded for the film.

    The interviews with Lorraine Dunbar presumably took place while she was inside (we see the actress playing her coming out of a jail right at the end of the film) – and the style adopted by Barnard may have something to do with protecting the visual identity of Lorraine and others.   But this clearly doesn’t apply to people who are already well known, like Max Stafford-Clark, who describes at one point going back to the Buttershaw estate in 2000 and interviewing people there.  What was said in those interviews subsequently comprised the script of a play, A State Affair, devised by Robin Soans and also performed at the Royal Court.   (Gary Whittaker, one of the cast of A State Affair, is the only person in the film who plays himself but he appears, for the sake of consistency, to be lip-synching his own words rather than speaking them normally.  I think I noticed that the credits show the character as ‘Whittaker’ and the actor as ‘Whitaker’ as if to respect this distinction.)  It seems likely that the way A State Affair developed is a main inspiration for the pivotal dramatic mode of The Arbor.  And because Andrea Dunbar put her life on stage in Brafferton Arbor it seems fitting (and to an extent ironic) for her posthumous legacy to be dramatised in the way chosen by Barnard.

    There are some major stylistic snags, though.  The scenes from Brafferton Arbor are presented and performed uncertainly.  The actors are speaking lines that were part of a theatre script; much of their style of acting comes over as stage acting (given that the play’s dialogue seems to consist largely of extended, heated arguments, less of it is overlapping than you would expect on screen, let alone in real life).  Yet Barnard and her director of photography Ole Bratt Birkeland shoot some of these exchanges as if they were conventional screen sequences – close-ups, reaction shots etc, which expose the mismatch between the camera style and the performance style.  In the first half of the film, which focuses on Andrea Dunbar’s life, the excerpts from the play (and, to a lesser extent, the lip-synching sequences) are upstaged by the documentary clips.  These reveal the Dunbar family as both more complex and, especially in the case of the father, more extraordinary looking than their counterparts in the dramatised version of their lives.  There’s an especially strong moment when the Arena interviewer asks Mr Dunbar if he’s going to go to London to see his daughter’s play.  He explains that his wife’s going but he has to stay and look after some of the other kids.  (Andrea was one of eight.)  You sense both his relief that he’s got this excuse and that he doesn’t really expect it to be believed.

    To start with, I feared that I would watch the lip-synching actors and do no more than assess their technical skill in carrying this off.  When an actor as recognisable as, say, Neil Dudgeon appears and speaks, it’s initially disorienting to hear a voice that isn’t his own when he moves his lips; you also wonder if the actor feels deprived by being silenced.  But he and others win you over.  They connect fully with their lines; they also use these words to create their own truth in what they give us to see in their faces and movements.  This is especially true of Dudgeon and Monica Dolan (as Steve and Ann, the couple who fostered both Andrea’s and Lorraine’s children at various times), George Costigan (as the second of the three men by whom Andrea had a child), Kathryn Pogson (as Andrea’s elder sister Pamela) and Jonathan Jaynes (as her younger brother David).  Some of this casting is pointed:  Pogson played the Andrea character in the original production of Brafferton Arbor; Costigan was Bob in the screen version of Rita, Sue and Bob, Too! (from which we see a single clip).    Until a few weeks ago Monica Dolan wasn’t an actress I’d noticed before:  since then I’ve seen her twice on television, as the stalker in the otherwise ropy U Be Dead then as the head teacher in the rather better Excluded.  She’s very good here as the kindly Ann:  it’s true that the real Ann’s voice is more lively and entertaining than most of the others’ but Dolan animates her with such empathetic skill that she becomes an almost tragic figure.

    Another benefit of the lip-synching is that it helps you believe in the honesty of the witnesses in a way that’s often not possible in fly-on-the-wall documentary, where you wonder how much the people on screen are playing up for the benefit of the camera and self-publicity.  Of course it’s possible that some of what is said here is untrue or exaggerated but I suspended disbelief almost entirely – again largely because what Dolan, Dudgeon et al were doing was unarguably truthful (that is to say, truthful acting).  Nevertheless, there’s a stylistic indecisiveness at work here, which tends to undermine their excellence.  Barnard doesn’t appear to make up her mind whether the lip-synched sequences are presented as a conventional documentary or as ‘found’ reality – that is, with the people shown not as if they were interrupting their normal lives for an interview but in more natural, everyday situations.    For example, there’s a sequence in which the couple played by Dudgeon and Dolan describe the death of Lorraine’s infant son.  Steve is sitting on a chair in the foreground, Ann on a settee in the background of the frame.  They both get very upset; Steve eventually moves to sit with Ann and they take each other’s hand.  According to documentary convention, the couple would have been sitting side by side from the start of the sequence.  It’s fine to defy convention but pointless to replace it with something that looks more false than the convention:  the physical separation of Ann and Steve and his movement towards her is too obviously designed to achieve a dramatic climax to the scene.

    Matthew McNulty seems very right in his brief appearance as Andrea’s son.  The two young actresses who play her daughters are less successful and it’s unfortunate that the main weakness in the cast is Manjinder Virk in the main part of Lorraine.  (Christine Bottomley is the younger daughter Lisa.)  The two things are clearly related:  Virk’s limitations would be less obvious if she had less screen time.  But she really isn’t good – especially once we realise that the interviews with Lorraine were recorded while she was in prison.   Her appearance is too sleek for one thing (Lorraine tells us that she’s ‘really pretty’:  Barnard seems to think we wouldn’t believe that if the actress playing her looked convincingly wasted).   The larger problem is Virk’s overacting and the mobility of her facial expressions, which contradict the dead, exhausted tones of the real Lorraine.  When she lists the attributes of a new boyfriend, Virk is gently smiling and hopeful – but the voice exposes her artificiality:  we can already hear the truth that’s coming.  (The boyfriend beat Lorraine up repeatedly.)  There are a few odd bits of casting too.  Danny Webb doubles up as Max Stafford-Clark and the drunken father of the family in Brafferton Arbor, although he does both well.   Jimi Mistry, who plays the boyfriend in the reconstructed play, is evidently much older than Natalie Gavin, who plays the Andrea figure, but no one comments on this.  You can’t tell whether that’s because the people are so racist that they notice only the colour of the boyfriend’s skin, or whether we’re supposed to accept Andrea and him as more or less the same age.

    Perhaps the grimmest moment in The Arbor is when Lorraine recalls how, as a young child, she heard Andrea come home from the pub one night and tell the man she was with that she regretted having given birth to Lorraine because she couldn’t give the same love to a mixed race child that she gave to her two other kids by white fathers. (Both the other daughter and the son speak kindly of their mother and seem baffled why Lorraine’s life has gone so wrong and why she’s so resentful of their mother.)   What intensifies the bleakness here isn’t Andrea’s admission so much as the way that it chimes with Lorraine’s having said at a previous point that she wishes she’d never been born.   We know from very early on in the film that Lorraine hasn’t forgiven and can’t forgive her mother for the life she left her with.  That limits the dramatic and documentary scope of what follows:  and, once Andrea has died and Lorraine’s inheritance is the main focus of the narrative (the structure is basically that of a two-act play), we know it’s going to be largely a matter of describing how bad things get.  Because the main interest of The Arbor lies in the way it’s put together, the question naturally arises of whether Clio Barnard is exploiting content for the sake of style – of whether, given the grimness of the content, this stylistic preoccupation is unseemly.  The older generations of actors are good enough, however, to rise above that difficulty:  Barnard has a lot to thank them for.   And, as a documentarist, she makes some strong, sad points about the Buttershaw estate.  To an observer, it looks to have been a gruesome place to live in the 1980s and not to have changed much since.   Yet we hear the people who’ve lived their lives there regretting the loss of community spirit over the years – they’re genuinely (which probably is to say falsely) nostalgic for the brutal culture which Andrea Dunbar dramatised in her stage plays.   The gloomy but supple music is by Harry Escott and Molly Nyman.

    25 October 2010

Posts navigation