Film review

  • The Grim Reaper

    La commare secca 

    Bernardo Bertolucci (1962)

    Bertolucci’s first feature, released when he was only twenty-two, is based on a short story by Pasolini.  The latter was busy making Mamma Roma so suggested to Antonio Cervi, who’d produced Accattone and bought the film rights to La commare secca, that he offer the piece to Bertolucci instead.   The body of a woman has been found close to the Tiber and the police are investigating her murder.  We watch a series of interviews (conducted by an unseen interrogator) with men who may or may not have been involved:  an unemployed youth who says he was meeting with priests at the time to try and get a reference for a job, although we see that he and his mates were actually trying to rob a couple; an ex-criminal; a soldier who tries unsuccessfully to pick up girls then falls asleep on a bench; another man, who wears white clogs that are as audible as they’re conspicuous; two teenage lads who meet first with their girlfriends then, later in the evening, are picked up by a homosexual, from whom they steal a cigarette lighter in the hope of selling it to raise the cash they’re desperate for.  Each episode centres on or leads the characters eventually to a wooded park.  Each is interrupted by a violent cloudburst (described in the BFI programme note and on Wikipedia as a ‘storm’ – which it doesn’t seem to be, although the noise of the rain has great impact).  At this point in each narrative, Bertolucci always returns to the woman who was murdered, a prostitute, whom we see in her bedsit, getting ready to go out for her last evening’s work.

    The multiple and sometimes untruthful testimonies, recounted at first in parallel but increasingly connected, suggest Rashomon (as does the torrential rain).  The walks through the underbelly of Rome and the intertwining of borderline criminal and gay lifestyles there – the succession of people who need money or sex or both – might seem indelibly Pasolini.  And yet The Grim Reaper feels entirely original.   At the start of the film a car crosses a bridge and the current of air it causes blows bits of newspaper off the bridge; they drift down towards the corpse that’s revealed lying on the embankment below.  The image immediately establishes a sense of both randomness and predetermination, and Bertolucci holds those two things in tension throughout.   While the prostitute’s fate feels predestined, the several police interviews and accounts of events of the previous day imply that any of the men  could have committed the crime – and the interactions of some of them with other women that we see suggest that it’s merely accidental that another crime wasn’t committed, someone different killed.  (The ex-criminal, for example, has a relationship with his viciously hard-faced girlfriend, and her even harder-faced mother, which seems always to be on the verge of violence.)   The Grim Reaper has an almost documentary reality; Bertolucci manages at the same time to dramatise the characters and their situations powerfully.

    There are visual and aural tensions too.  The chiaroscuro of the Roman side streets and their tunnels, the interplay of bright sunlight and shadows, is mesmerising.  (The film was shot in black and white, and photographed by Giovanni Narzisi.)   The silence of a hot summer day is given a beautifully sinister quality, which occasional snatches of pop music on transistor radios do little to dispel.  When the rain falls the sound is both alarming and relieving.   The calmest place in the story is the prostitute’s room, which seems cloistered and pacific compared with the various things going on outside it.  Barely out of his teens, Bertolucci had developed an extraordinary sense of rhythm:  the film moves fluidly and excitingly – especially in the sequence when the two teenage boys are running to escape the police and one of them dives into and swims across a lake.  (When he disappears from view under the water, you wonder for a moment if there’s been a new death to upstage the one at the centre of the film.)  The cast includes Vanda Rocci (the prostitute), Allen Midgette (the soldier), Alvaro d’Ercole and Romano Labate (the teenage boys) and Silvio Laurenzi (the gay picker-up, played in a way that looks nearly homophobic now although Laurenzi is physically convincing).  The intriguing music – which has a formal, antique elegance – is by Piero Picchioni and Carlo Rustichelli.

    The BFI screened as an appetiser for The Grim Reaper Bertolucci’s contribution to the portmanteau film Amore e rabbia.  (The other contributors were Marco Bellocchio and Elda Tattoli (jointly), Godard, Carlo Lizzani and Pasolini.)   Agonia opens with a dying man being told by his nurse that a priest has arrived to administer the last rites.  The man complains that the priest is too early (‘He’s already been twice’) and puts his head under the covers.  At the very end of the piece, which runs some twenty-five minutes, his corpse is kitted out in a cardinal’s vestments.  Between the witty opening and the punchline, Agonia is like (perhaps is meant to be) a satire of a drama workshop, with a group of people in the room next door to the death chamber doing a lot of laborious movement, groaning, drooling, carrying the bare-bottomed dying man aloft etc.  (The latter turns out not to be very old at all; he’s played by Julian Beck, who was in his early forties at the time.)   If Agonia had been the piece of Bertolucci juvenilia it feels like, its inclusion in the programme would have been understandable – but it was made several years after the precociously brilliant main feature, in 1969.

    Postscript   Sally described Agonia as ‘East 15 on a very bad day’ and was so irritated by the time The Grim Reaper started that she walked out after not very long, and missed a treat as a result.  I was doubly sorry she wasn’t there at the very end of the film because I’m pretty sure that, when we stayed in Rome in 2004, we regularly went through via Giulia en route to the bridge over the Tiber and this is where Bertolucci closes The Grim Reaper – his camera on a marble slab bearing the inscription ‘E già la Commaraccia secca de strada Giulia arza er rampino[1]’.  Sally would have known for certain.  The only consolation was that because Agonia was described as a ‘fragment’, it got me talking about Eliot and wondering if the two things were somehow connected:  once we’d got home and looked at ‘Fragment of a Prologue’ and ‘Fragment of an Agon’, it was clear they weren’t.  But I have this aberration to thank for the chance to reread ‘Sweeney Agonistes’.

    10 April 2011

    [1]  ‘And already the skinny mean lady of via Giulia lifts her hook’.

  • Hitchcock

    Sacha Gervasi (2012)

    In the autumn of 2005, Bennett Miller’s Capote was released to critical acclaim – especially for Philip Seymour Hoffman’s performance in the title role.  At the time, Douglas McGrath was making Infamous, which covered virtually the same territory as the Miller film, with Toby Jones as Truman Capote.  When Infamous appeared in the second half of 2006, Jones received a lot of praise but by then Hoffman had won an Oscar and many other prizes for his Capote.  The Girl, about Alfred Hitchcock’s relationship with Tippi Hedren and starring Toby Jones, was shown on HBO in late October 2012 (and on BBC on Boxing Day).  Within the month, Sacha Gervasi’s Hitchcock, with Anthony Hopkins in the lead, was in American cinemas and it has now arrived in British ones.  It isn’t Capote all over again.  Gervasi’s film is about the making of Psycho, not The Birds and Marnie, and Hopkins isn’t going to win an Academy Award.  Even so, Toby Jones could be forgiven for reflecting on how much his physical extraordinariness limits the screen parts he gets, and for wondering how often he‘s going to be cast in roles for which the likes of Philip Seymour Hoffman and Anthony Hopkins are physically better suited.

    Gwyneth Hughes’s screenplay for The Girl is based on Donald Spoto’s 2009 book Spellbound by Beauty: Alfred Hitchcock and His Leading Ladies.   If it’s anything like an accurate account of Hitchcock’s treatment of Tippi Hedren (this is much disputed), The Girl is almost bound to make you feel sympathy for Hedren and watch her in The Birds and Marnie in a different light.   I’m not sure it’s true that her refusal to be controlled by Hitchcock – including resisting his sexual advances – effectively stunted her career.  Hedren wasn’t much of an actress and would probably not have had a career as one if Hitchcock hadn’t liked the look of her.   But if Hitchcock subjected Hedren to what Julian Jarrold and Gwyneth Hughes show it’s not surprising that her look in The Birds is increasingly glazed and stunned.  I’m prepared to believe Hitchcock was a sexual pest and manipulator.  This isn’t for a censorious thrill and, if it’s true, I don’t think it diminishes him as an artist – except that perhaps it further coarsens his blatant use of blondes in his movies.  But the tendency of many film-makers and cinéastes to see a genius auteur as above the law (evidenced  in reactions to Roman Polanski’s house arrest in Switzerland in 2009) tends to bring out the reactionary in me in matters of this kind.

    Toby Jones’s portrait of Hitchcock is brilliant.  You soon forget that this is an actor doing an impression, even as you keep hearing distinctly the Leytonstone vowels.  The thick, curdled voice and the excess weight (though Jones doesn’t look quite heavy enough) function as layers of protection and expressions of self-disgust.  Quite early on in The Girl, Hitchcock tells someone it’s a well-known fact that he has no sense of humour.  You assume he’s being ironic but one of the fascinating things about Toby Jones’s performance is that he distinguishes wit, which his Hitchcock has in abundance, from humour.  (You’re aware of this especially in his delivery of the filthy limericks that Hitchcock is partial to.)  Sienna Miller is very effective as Tippi Hedren: you can see what Hitchcock sees in her, and Miller is able to make Hedren more expressive ‘off screen’ than on camera.  Imelda Staunton as Alma Reville and Penelope Wilton as Hitchcock’s secretary Peggy Robertson are both excellent.  They function as a very singular double act:  two women who know the rules of the game, who admire Hitchcock and are his helpmates, and who realise the humiliating aspect of complete loyalty.  Julian Jarrold has an impressive track record in TV drama – Great Expectations in 1999, the best of the Red Riding films, Appropriate Adult in 2011.  His direction here is taut and Gwyneth Hughes’s script (she also adapted The Mystery of Edwin Drood for television) is intelligent and well organised.  The Girl was absorbing television, thanks both to its subject and the way it was done.  Its limitation, eventually a serious one, was that it didn’t develop beyond its first hour:  the last thirty minutes were anti-climactic as drama – they merely reiterated points that had already been fully made.

    The Girl may present a narrow point of view but its sharp single-mindedness makes it far superior to the tame, inert Hitchcock.  John McLaughlin (who co-wrote the ridiculous Black Swan) based his screenplay on a 1990 book by Stephen Rebello called Alfred Hitchcock and the Making of Psycho.  The story could make a fine documentary but McLaughlin and Sacha Gervasi are unsure whether their subject is the story of Psycho or the story of Hitchcock’s marriage, and the result isn’t interesting in either department.  Gervasi never finds a secure tone:  until the last few minutes, when Psycho opens in cinemas, Hitchcock is treading water.  Alma’s friendship with the screenwriter Whitfield Cook (Stage Fright, Strangers on a Train) doesn’t amount to anything; given how dull Danny Huston makes him, it’s baffling that even the notoriously possessive Hitchcock should be worried his wife may be having an affair with ‘Whit’.   There’s scope for a lively lampoon of Hollywood attitudes here but no consistency even in the presentation of the film industry people:  the Paramount boss Barney Balaban (Richard Portnow) is a cartoon; Hitchcock’s agent (Michael Stuhlbarg) and the censor (Kurtwood Smith) are colourless.

    The crudeness of the characters McLaughlin has written makes you wonder if the material might have been better played for comedy; the lack of wit in the lines makes you think again.  I laughed twice:  first, at a bit I’d seen several times in the trailer for Hitchcock, when Helen Mirren as Alma advises her husband to kill off Marion Crane after thirty minutes rather than halfway through and crunches decisively on a piece of toast to underline the point; then, near the end, when Hitchcock tells Alma she means more to him than all his screen blondes, she says she’s been waiting thirty years to hear him say that, and he replies, ‘That’s why they call me the Master of Suspense’.   The audience reactions to the shower scene at the first screening of Psycho, and Hitchcock’s waiting at the back of the theatre for the screams, are mildly amusing, if obviously staged.  But when Peggy Robertson watches the film and says, ‘I don’t think I’ll ever take a shower again’, McLaughlin seems to be recycling jokes about Psycho that everyone already knows.  The brief early sequence in which Ed Gein, the Wisconsin serial killer who provided Robert Bloch with the inspiration for Norman Bates, whacks his brother with a spade, supplies the movie’s only startling moment.  Hitchcock’s imagined conversations with Gein are unimaginative and mechanical – they play as if the film-makers had showing Hitchcock’s dark, haunted imagination as something written down on a ‘to do’ list.

    Anthony Hopkins does a creditable job as Hitchcock but he’s wrong for the part.  With prosthetic, padding (which isn’t very good) and a lot of skill, Hopkins pretends to have a comical appearance but his natural air of distinction keeps emerging:  no one would laugh at how Anthony Hopkins looks the way they might laugh at the real Hitchcock (or Toby Jones).   Hitchcock surely exploited and emphasised his unprepossessing face and body – made himself appear almost despicably innocuous and an unlikely purveyor of fear.  (There’s a kinship here with the stereotypically harmless-looking but lethal husband of mid-twentieth century English suburban murders in fact and fiction.)   Occasionally we’re meant to see the vulnerable side of Hitchcock and Hopkins gets these moments across with ease.  Elsewhere, he often seems like a waxwork and his painstaking impersonation tends to slow things up – not that the film was zipping along anyway.  Watching Hopkins and Helen Mirren as Alma Reville is a reminder of an actor’s relative freedom if the real-life person they’re playing isn’t well known to the viewer.  That freedom – from audience expectation and prosthetic – allows Mirren to suggest a human being but her innate authority throws the story out of balance.   She suggests a naturally glamorous woman past her youth, whose admiration for her husband as an artist is in conflict with her distress at his infidelity to her in everything but the actual sexual deed.  Alma Reville never was a beauty; you can believe that, whatever she felt about dutifully following her famous husband around in public, she would have been able to do so unobtrusively.  With Helen Mirren in the role, you don’t believe that Alma would have been so loyally tolerant – or that the press wouldn’t have been photographing her.

    The actors playing actors in Hitchcock appear to have been asked by Sacha Gervasi to mimic the characterisations in Psycho.  Scarlet Johansson does well enough as the centred Janet Leigh/Marion Crane but James D’Arcy’s Anthony Perkins is hopeless – an impression of a dim version of Norman Bates.  It’s easier for Jessica Biel as Vera Miles since Lila Crane is hardly a memorable character; because of Hitchcock’s treatment of Miles, this element of Gervasi’s film, although nothing special, is relatively realised (as well as closer than any other element to the theme of The Girl).  Toni Collette is striking as Peggy Robertson but both her presence and her acting seem too sophisticated for the character (or the one she’s been given to play, at any rate).

    Whereas The Girl is unkind to Hitchcock, this cinema film wants to play safe with his reputation:  Sacha Gervasi presents Hitch as ‘a character’ (in the euphemistic sense of the word) and him and Alma, in the bland finale, as a-nice-happy-couple-really.  Legends at the end remind us that Hitchcock famously never won an Oscar.  Although he didn’t win a competitive Oscar, he was given an honorary award in 1968:  since the legend goes on to report that he received the AFI Life Achievement Award, it seems odd not to mention the Academy’s honour more than a decade earlier.  One of the few genuinely mysterious moments in the film occurs when Hitchcock is reading a newspaper with the headline ‘The King Speaks to Every Briton’, eight years after the accession of Queen Elizabeth II.   Perhaps you would need the Master of Suspense to make this story a surprising one in terms of how things turn out but Hitchcock makes its protagonist seem rather innocuous and Psycho a bit boring.  This is quite a feat.

    27 December 2012 (The Girl), 9 February 2013 (Hitchcock)

Posts navigation